| Rank | Name | Score | Date | Event | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alex Bourdage | 1147 | Mar 4–5, 2017 | 2017 USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Myers Field House, Mankato, MN |
| 2 | Noah Cagle | 1136 | Feb 12–13, 2022 | 53rd USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Minneapolis Marriott NW, Brooklyn Park, MN |
| 3 | Robert Young | 1091 | Unknown | 2008 MAA 18-Meter Championship | Unknown |
| 4 | Steven Tiongson | 1063 | Dec 29–30, 2018 | 2019 USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Myers Field House, Mankato, MN |
| 5 | Michael Larson | 1061 | Feb 18–19, 2023 | 54th USA Archery Indoor Nationals | St. Michael-Albertville Middle School West, Albertville, MN |
| 6 | Michael Larson | 1056 | Feb 22–23, 2025 | 56th USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Rockford Community Center, Rockford, MN |
| 7 | Steven Tiongson | 1053 | Mar 3–4, 2018 | 2018 USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Myers Field House, Mankato, MN |
| 8 | Steven Tiongson | 984 | Feb 18–19, 2023 | 54th USA Archery Indoor Nationals | St. Michael-Albertville Middle School West, Albertville, MN |
| 9 | Blake Dandurand | 951 | Feb 18–19, 2023 | 54th USA Archery Indoor Nationals | St. Michael-Albertville Middle School West, Albertville, MN |
| 10 | Ernesto Cruz, Jr. | 949 | Feb 12–13, 2022 | 53rd USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Minneapolis Marriott NW, Brooklyn Park, MN |
| 11 | Kristopher Wilson | 938 | Mar 3–4, 2018 | 2018 USA Archery Indoor Nationals | Myers Field House, Mankato, MN |
| 12 | Todd Heck | 933 | Jan 27–28, 2007 | 2007 MAA 18-Meter Championship | Southwest Bow Benders, Worthington, MN |